JohnLottsWebsite

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Sunday, June 9, 2013

Very sloppy claims that more government funding is necessary on guns

Posted on 2:52 PM by Unknown
I get that researchers always want more money, but people have to take those desires with a grain of salt.  Just because researchers want more taxpayer money, doesn't mean that it is really needed.  From the New York Times:
. . . President Obama has included $10 million for gun-related research in his 2014 budget, the first federal financing for the topic in years, and the panel’s chairman, Alan I. Leshner, said the report was a first step to deepen evidence about the public health implications of guns. The panel was assembled by the Institute of Medicine and the National Research Council at President Obama’s request.
“Policies are made on the basis of facts and values, and we are the facts people,” said Mr. Leshner, who is the chief executive of the American Association for the Advancement of Science. “We are trying to provide a tool for the country to address this very difficult issue more productively than it has been able to do in the past.”
Among the panel’s recommendations was a call for better data on guns. For example, there is no national count of how many guns there are in the country. And while federal law enforcement authorities, like the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, gather data on specific guns, they track only those used in crimes, and often the details are not accessible to researchers. One database, the National Violent Death Reporting System, which compiles information on deaths from police departments and medical examiners’ offices, covers only about a third of the states. . . .
The problem is also that creating this data isn't bias free.  The people who create it could have a political agenda and the concern is that the Obama administration could use political criteria on who they decide to give the money too.  The lopsided bias in terms of how this report was put together shows why we shouldn't trust the Obama administration to look at these issues objectively.

A copy of the report is available here.  Here is what the study writes on concealed carry research:
Even when defensive use of guns is effective in averting death or injury for the gun user in cases of crime, it is still possible that keeping a gun in the home or carrying a gun in public—concealed or open carry— may have a different net effect on the rate of injury. For example, if gun ownership raises the risk of suicide, homicide, or the use of weapons by those who invade the homes of gun owners this could cancel or outweigh the beneficial effects of defensive gun use (Kellermann et al., 1992, 1993, 1995). Although some early studies were published that relate to this issue, they were not conclusive, and this is a sufficiently important question that it merits additional, careful exploration. . . . . 
Seriously?  They act as if no research has been done on these questions since 1995, and I wouldn't even count Kellermann's research as providing serious research.  His research did a poor job of looking at the risks of guns in the home.  Yet, they make a claim that more research is needed in this area without even acknowledging all the research that has already been done.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in ObamaGunControl | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Lois Lerner knew that rogue agents in Cincinnati weren't responsible for the IRS scandal because she was involved herself
    With this information coming out, it is understandable that Obama chose Friday for speaking out on the Zimmerman case.  From National Review...
  • Even Moderate and Conservative turn against Obamacare
    The poll results are available here .
  • Newest piece in the New York Post: The real hole in the border bill
    My newest piece starts this way: As the Senate begins to debate immigration-overhaul legislation today, skeptics of the bill are focusing on...
  • Audio of my interview with Mike Huckabee on the Zimmerman case yesterday
    The Huckabee interview is available here .
  • New Quinnipiac poll of Colorado voter shows most oppose state's new gun control laws
    From Quinnipiac University: . . .  All voters oppose 54 - 40 percent the stricter new gun control laws which led to the recall effort. Demo...
  • Obama administration secretly eliminated Bush limits on NSA's use of intercepted phone calls and e-mails
    Several key points here.  1) The Obama administration greatly expanded the intrusiveness of these searches from what the Bush administration...
  • Washington Post/ABC News: "Eighty-six percent of African Americans disapproved of the not guilty verdict [in Zimmerman case] with just 9 percent approving"
    Here is my puzzle: Hispanics and Blacks make up the same share of the Washington Post/ABC News sample, but they only report the breakdown fo...
  • Obama comments interfere with military legal cases
    Obama has made comments on everything from the Zimmerman case to the police arrest of Henry Louis Gates in Cambridge .  Some of those commen...
  • Jonathan Alter book gets only 3 of his 13 claims about Roger Ailes "at least partially correct," the rest "patently, provably false"
    What three allegations did Alter get partially correct?  See below.  Politico as the other ten as well.  Did Alter even bother to get two so...
  • IRS scandal hassled broad range of conservative groups
    As someone who recently tried to set up a 501(C)(3), the law is very simple: you make a proposal and the IRS is just supposed to check to se...

Categories

  • 2014elections (1)
  • 3D Printed Gun (4)
  • Academia (1)
  • accidentaldeaths (2)
  • alcohol (1)
  • AlGore (1)
  • APgate (11)
  • apple (1)
  • At the Brink (2)
  • Athletes (1)
  • austerity (2)
  • AustinGoolsbee (2)
  • Australia (2)
  • background checks (11)
  • bailout (1)
  • BATF (3)
  • Benghazi (7)
  • Bill Maher (1)
  • billclinton (1)
  • Bloomberg (2)
  • brokenpromiseshealthcare (3)
  • brokenpromisesobama (3)
  • CampaignFinanceRegulation (4)
  • CassSunstein (1)
  • CastleLaw (18)
  • Chicago (2)
  • china (2)
  • civilrights (1)
  • classwarfare (1)
  • Coase Theorem (1)
  • Colorado Recalls (10)
  • ConcealedCarry (27)
  • confirmations (1)
  • Corruption (2)
  • Cory Booker (1)
  • Crime (4)
  • DefensiveGunUse (18)
  • deficits (3)
  • Democrats (5)
  • DemocratsturningonObama (1)
  • DONATIONgate (1)
  • Economics (2)
  • Economy (13)
  • education (2)
  • efficiency (1)
  • electric cars (3)
  • Environment (7)
  • EPA (2)
  • EPAgate (2)
  • EricHolder (4)
  • evolution (1)
  • filibuster (1)
  • FirstAmendment (2)
  • foxnews (1)
  • Fun (3)
  • GDP (1)
  • george zimmerman (33)
  • Germany (2)
  • GlobalWarming (3)
  • GM (1)
  • Google (3)
  • Government (1)
  • governmentcontrol (2)
  • governmentintimidation (1)
  • governmentwaste (2)
  • Gun Control Organizations (1)
  • Gun Control Poll (1)
  • gun licensing (2)
  • gun taxes (1)
  • gunbuybacks (1)
  • gunconfiscation (1)
  • GunControl (26)
  • GunFreeZone (19)
  • gunlocks (1)
  • gunownershiprate (1)
  • gunregistration (2)
  • Guns (1)
  • Guns in Media (1)
  • Health (2)
  • Hillary Clinton Corruption (1)
  • HillaryClinton (2)
  • homosexualmarriage (4)
  • Hunting (1)
  • hypocrisy of gun control advocates (2)
  • IllegalAliens (3)
  • illinois (5)
  • Immigration (9)
  • Incentives (1)
  • indoctrination (3)
  • insidertrading (1)
  • IRSgate (40)
  • Israel (1)
  • JoeBiden (2)
  • Judiciary (2)
  • Kathleen Sebelius (3)
  • Knife (1)
  • magazine limit (1)
  • Marc Rubio (1)
  • Mayors Against Illegal Guns (12)
  • MediaAppearance (10)
  • mediabias (14)
  • mental illness (1)
  • mental illness gun control (1)
  • menversuswomen (1)
  • Mexico (1)
  • MGLC (2)
  • MGLCreviews (1)
  • multiplevictimcarattack (2)
  • multiplevictimnongunattacks (2)
  • multiplevictimpublicshooters (5)
  • muslim (1)
  • newjersey (1)
  • NICS (1)
  • nikkigoeser (1)
  • Norway (1)
  • NSAgate (18)
  • Obama (2)
  • Obama Foreign Policy (12)
  • Obama Waste (3)
  • ObamaAdministration (1)
  • Obamaantibusiness (1)
  • ObamaCampaign (1)
  • obamacare (32)
  • ObamaCorruption (14)
  • ObamaDishonest (10)
  • obamadoesntunderstandeconomics (2)
  • ObamaGunControl (18)
  • obamajudicialappointments (1)
  • obamalawless (14)
  • ObamaMisstatement (1)
  • Obamaphone (1)
  • Obamaprivacy (3)
  • obamataxes (2)
  • op-ed (17)
  • OpenCarry (1)
  • Other (1)
  • paulkrugman (2)
  • PhotoID (2)
  • Police (4)
  • Police State in US (1)
  • PoliticalCorrectness (1)
  • Politics (2)
  • poll (9)
  • postedgunfreezone (4)
  • predation (1)
  • privacy (2)
  • privatization (4)
  • prostitution (1)
  • pseudonym (6)
  • public health (2)
  • racialdiscrimination (9)
  • Radio (8)
  • redistributionofincome (1)
  • Regulation (9)
  • religion (3)
  • Research (1)
  • schoolsecurity (8)
  • Science (2)
  • Secret Email gate (1)
  • Sheriff David Clarke (2)
  • slavery (1)
  • sports (1)
  • StateDepartmentgate (1)
  • stimulus (7)
  • StudentsforCConCampus (4)
  • subsidies (1)
  • SupremeCourt (3)
  • Sweden (1)
  • Syria (4)
  • Talks (1)
  • taser (1)
  • Taxes (3)
  • TeachersGuns (1)
  • technology changing humans (1)
  • technologycausingcrime (1)
  • technologysavinglives (1)
  • technologysolvingcrime (1)
  • TedCruz (1)
  • TedNugent (1)
  • television (2)
  • Terrorism (2)
  • thugishgovernment (3)
  • transparency (4)
  • UK (3)
  • unemployment (8)
  • Unions (2)
  • vegetarian (1)
  • VerizonGate (2)
  • VoteFraud (6)
  • voting (1)
  • welfare (1)
  • Wikipedia (2)
  • women crime victim (1)
  • ZeroTolerance (4)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  September (71)
    • ►  August (131)
    • ►  July (94)
    • ▼  June (91)
      • Even the New York Times concedes that Zimmerman's ...
      • CNN shows bias in discussion of the Supreme Court ...
      • Are taxes the secret weapon in the gun control deb...
      • Obama's EPA Regulatory Overreach in One Diagram
      • Has the NSA collected massive data on all American...
      • Are you smarter than the President? How many membe...
      • Two Dozen House Republicans propose plan for conce...
      • Devastating blow to prosecution in Zimmerman case,...
      • Is Obama serious that the Supreme Court homosexual...
      • Audio version of "At the Brink" is now available!
      • Eric Holder's "sixteen scandals"
      • Here is what I think is the key quote from Kennedy...
      • Obama administration lining up NFL, NBA and Hollyw...
      • Dramatic diagram: Pathetic GDP growth, first recov...
      • IRS agents use government issued credit cards to p...
      • The Mayors Against Illegal Guns's “No More Names” ...
      • Bias in The Hill story about Supreme Court decisio...
      • How to predict which Supreme Court Justice will wr...
      • Democrat Colorado Senate President John Morse is d...
      • Shooting spree in China leaves six dead
      • iPhone saves man's life in New Zealand who was tra...
      • Concealed handgun permit holder stops armed robber...
      • Sun City, AZ homeowner wounds armed man who broke ...
      • Joe Biden claims that five Senators want to change...
      • "Is Michael Bloomberg Using City Resources For His...
      • Texans equally divided on letting concealed handgu...
      • Obama IRS gives Union-tied group special treatment
      • Obama administration made it very difficult for me...
      • Gun control group counts terrorist killed by polic...
      • The long term (may be permanent) damage Obama has ...
      • Obama's "Organizing For Action" quickly granted ta...
      • Very few people show up the Obama orchestrated gun...
      • Democrats are trying to destroy IRS investigation
      • Environmentalists excited: It takes 63% longer to ...
      • What Republicans might do when they get control of...
      • Obama defends NSA spying on Americans as "transpar...
      • Vote Fraud in Indiana
      • The Obama administration believes everyone will st...
      • Audio from my hosting Jason Lewis Show on June 13t...
      • IRS and NSA concerns collide in poll
      • It is too bad that this bill wasn't a law a few ye...
      • North Carolina is close to expanding where conceal...
      • CBS confirms that Sharyl Attkisson's computer was ...
      • With six month anniversary of Newtown, Obama and B...
      • Even Cornyn's amendment to Immigration Bill keeps ...
      • If Obama thinks that gun-free zones are such a gre...
      • Horrible story of retired Vet who went in for coun...
      • When Bill "Mr. Triangulation" criticizes Obama for...
      • Obama's push for gun control, not going away
      • Newest piece in the New York Post: The real hole i...
      • A very detailed review in "The Free Market" of my ...
      • The remarkable partisan shift on NSA tracking your...
      • Very sloppy claims that more government funding is...
      • Job Growth in the current recovery has continued t...
      • Gallup: Democrats are much less informed about IRS...
      • Free gun initiative starts in Houston
      • Another gun free zone, another shooting: Santa Mon...
      • Shannon Richardson, who wrote the Ricin letters th...
      • Obama's monitoring of reporters has chilled news s...
      • IRS leaks names of conservative donors to liberal ...
      • Are we moving to being in a police state?: Mark Le...
      • Attorney General Holder refuses to answer question...
      • Jonathan Alter book gets only 3 of his 13 claims a...
      • Evidence that the Zero Tolerance approach on guns ...
      • Boy Suspended for saying the word "Gun," incredibl...
      • McClatchy Newspapers: No Democrat groups were targ...
      • Scott Adams' Dilbert cartoon provides a very reali...
      • IRS gave employees leather bags and other gifts to...
      • Which side cares most passionately about the gun c...
      • Democrats misleading argument for health care bene...
      • Democrats in Connecticut think that it is up to th...
      • IRS refusing to release documents requested by Sen...
      • NICS checks had begun to slow down in May
      • New York State Sheriffs' Association joins lawsuit...
      • Despite Obama's claims, top Obama official did lea...
      • Democrats don't want to stop immigrants voting, bu...
      • Obama Scandals number #5 and #6 just since the pre...
      • Jay Leno: Obama should close IRS instead of Gitmo,...
      • Voter Fraud in Florida and Ohio
      • Caddell, Schoen, and LeBoutillier provide an inter...
      • More than 2xs as many signatures as needed turned ...
      • Former EPA Administrator Lisa Jackson's fictional ...
      • "Special Report" Online: Is IRS Still Targeting Co...
      • Obama keeps trying to pick winners with taxpayer m...
      • Will Medicaid expansion occur in Arizona, Ohio, an...
      • Milwaukee Sheriff David Clarke educates Piers Morg...
      • IRS Dance Video: Your tax dollars spent wisely
      • A couple of interesting fast food facts
      • Actor Woody Harrelson on Obama
      • The Obama administration scandal that is being ign...
      • Illinois finally adopts concealed carry law: All s...
    • ►  May (113)
Powered by Blogger.